

Trade secrets – the ‘secret sauce’ to a successful IP strategy?
In these pages, we have talked at some length about the importance of hard IP rights such as patents in providing defensibility and capturing value in alternative protein. It is true that these are extremely important for realizing future value in this sector, with large numbers of patents continuing to be filed every year. However, there is a lesser-known IP right with just as important a role to play in IP portfolios – they are powerful, they are cheap, and chances are you already have one without even realizing it. Indeed, across the food technology sector, trade secrets are long-established as an effective way of securing exclusivity in a very competitive landscape.
Trade secrets are a special class of confidential information. To qualify, a trade secret must be commercially valuable because it is secret, be known only to a limited group of people, and be subject to reasonable steps taken by the rightful holder to keep it secret, including the use of confidentiality agreements with business partners and employees. In return, trade secrets offer strong legal protection and meaningful remedies in the event of a breach. However, a major downside is that trade secrets are “brittle” and easily lost through disclosure, whether accidental or malicious. In other words, once the cat is out of the bag, you cannot put it back in.
One vital role trade secrets play in alternative protein companies is protecting information that would otherwise not be suitable for patents or other registered IP rights. For example, it is notoriously difficult to obtain a patent for a recipe. The culinary arts are subjective, and it is challenging to demonstrate that ‘better tasting’ represents a technical invention rather than preference. At the same time, copyright protection only prevents third parties from reproducing the text of a recipe, not recreating it independently. Trade secrets therefore seem tailor-made for maintaining exclusivity around recipes, as illustrated by the enduring reference to the ‘Coca-Cola Secret Recipe’.
In a fast-moving and competitive sector, the secret ingredient may well lie in what you choose not to disclose
This highlights another role for trade secrets in defending alternative protein technology: if secrecy can be maintained, the scope of protection may be indefinite. This is particularly relevant for production processes that take place behind closed doors. A highly efficient fermentation schedule, or an incubation temperature that reduces off-flavors, may be completely undetectable in the final product and impossible to reverse-engineer from what appears on the shelf. Information of this kind can be extremely valuable to preserve as a trade secret.
It is relatively rare for trade secrets to form the ‘core’ of an IP portfolio in alternative protein. Yet even in patent-heavy portfolios, trade secrets play a crucial supporting role. Patent disclosures require applicants to provide at least one way of producing the patented product or implementing the patented process. However, this does not amount to a full manual for commercial operation. Optimizations for large-scale production or efficiency improvements are highly valuable, and retaining control over them significantly increases the practical value of patented technology. Even if a third party were able to design around a patent, doing so would be far more costly
if months were required to ‘dial in’ a commercially viable process. Trade secrets also protect unpatented inventions that are still in development. Together, these overlapping IP rights create a dense thicket of defensibility, raising legal, technical, and economic barriers to entry.
That said, trade secrets are not a ‘cheap’ or ‘easy’ route to exclusivity. The most common mistake companies make is failing to appreciate the investment required to maintain a fit-for-purpose trade secret policy. Beyond being a prerequisite for legal protection, a robust policy reduces the risk of disclosure in the first place. Effective policies address training, data retention, and monitoring of sensitive information. While this may seem daunting, putting such systems in place strengthens exclusivity and sends a powerful signal to potential investors that their capital is protected by a serious defensive moat.
In conclusion, while patents remain central to IP strategy in the alternative protein space, trade secrets offer a vital and complementary layer of protection. In a fast-moving and competitive sector, the true ‘secret ingredient’ may lie in what you choose not to disclose.
Andrew Tindall is a Patent Director and patent attorney at HGF, based in London. He has a special interest in the technologies shaping the futures of food science, having spent his career working with alternative protein clients ranging from startups to investors and multinationals. This article is republished from the Q4 2025 edition of Protein Production Technology International, the industry's leading resource for alternative proteins. To subscribe to all future editions, please click here
If you have any questions or would like to get in touch with us, please email info@futureofproteinproduction.com
More Opinion

Food biomanufacturing: A national security issue

Creating a new protein sector: Part II

Trade secrets: when, how and why to use them

The criticality of conducting LCAs

Creating a new protein sector: Part I

Protecting IP on a budget

Will the UK become the new Singapore?








